1361 E 3rd Avenue

Durango CO, 81122


This lovely historic Queen Anne style Victorian known as The Judge's House, was built in 1888 by Judge George Sumner and has been an integral part of Durangos history and the home of many of its influential citizens for 130 years. The home is a well proportioned two-story structure built from wood, stucco and large stone blocks quarried from native sandstone. The gracious floor plan and much of its original style is very much intact. The home has had careful restoration over the years with a lot of the heavy work done as much of the wiring and plumbing has been replaced, sewer line, blown-in insulation added, a new roof, and an entire radiant under-floor heating system. The details and aesthetics of kitchen and baths can be envisioned by the next owner. Beautiful trim work and large windows still grace these high-ceilinged rooms that feel light and spacious. The formal entry encompasses the original staircase with the parlor and stone fireplace to the north, where the Judge is said to have held court, and the sitting room with en-suite library to the south. The flowing floor plan opens into a formal dining room, complete with crystal chandelier and built in hutch with charming original hardware. The breakfast room, with muntined windows and views of the La Platas, was built by the second judge, Judge Searcy, in 1919 along with many of his upgrades. The stairs to the upper level exhibit an unusual wood rail and detail, leading to a cozy landing alcove and views west. On this floor is the master with a sitting room en-suite (room for a possible future master bath), two other bedrooms and a bonus room that could serve as a nursery, office or hobby/playroom. The second full bathroom is off the hall with two sinks and a period built-in. This home is on a very large 10,481 sf lot, right downtown and has a reinstated old carriage house, now studio/storage space, in the huge back yard. Expanded uses should be checked with the city. This property is registered in the Historic 3rd Avenue Boulevard District and is subject to Historical Guidelines and approval of changes by the Boulevard Association. The City of Durango administers and these can be found on their website. This is an incredibly unique property and must be felt to be appreciated. If you recognize the craftsmanship of days gone by and are intrigued with history you will be drawn to this lovely home.


Listing TypeFor Sale
Days On Site142


Bath(s) 2 Full
SQ Feet2,511
Story(s)Two Story

Additional Information

HeatingBoiler,Floor Radiant
Interior FeaturesWindow Coverings,Wired/Cable TV,W/D Hookup,Skylight(s),Pantry
Available AmenitiesElectric,Natural Gas,Cable TV,Internet,Phone - Cell Reception

Market Activity 81122

Loading Form

Loading Form

Area Information

CountyLa Plata
Zip Code81122
AreaDurango In Town
Community NameFassbinder
Middle SchoolEscalante 6-8
High SchoolDurango 9-12
Listing VS Median (in Fassbinder)
low | high
25.516055045872% of Average
low | high
34.587813620072% of Average
$ / SqFt:
low | high
43.06569687068% of Average
On Site:
low | high
73.766233766234% of Average
Listing Updated: 02/22/2020
MLS Number: 763663
Listing Provided By:
Sara Staber  of  Keller Williams Realty Southwest Associates LLC

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of Colorado Real Estate Network, Inc. (CREN), © Copyright 2017. All rights reserved. All data deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This database record is provided subject to "limited license" rights. Duplication or reproduction is prohibited.
FULL CREN Disclaimer

Real Estate listings held by companies other than 2104:66 contain that company's name.
Fair Housing Disclaimer